A garage fire can spread quickly and cause damage to the building, the belongings stored inside, and any vehicle parked there. That raises an important insurance question: Does the homeowners policy cover the car, or does the auto policy pay?
The answer is that different property is generally handled by different coverage.
What the homeowners policy may cover
If fire is a covered cause of loss, homeowners insurance may help pay for damage to your house or an attached garage. A detached garage is generally addressed under the policy’s “other structures” coverage, subject to its own limit. Covered household belongings in the garage may also fall under personal property coverage.
Every policy has conditions, exclusions, limits, and deductibles, so the exact result depends on the individual policy and facts of the loss.
What covers the vehicle?
A personal vehicle is generally not covered as household personal property under a homeowners policy. Fire damage to the vehicle is normally handled by comprehensive coverage—sometimes called other-than-collision coverage—on the auto policy.
Comprehensive coverage commonly protects against non-collision losses such as fire, theft, vandalism, hail, falling objects, and certain weather events. It is optional unless a lender or leasing company requires it. If a vehicle carries liability-only coverage, there may be no coverage for fire damage to that vehicle.
Removing the plates does not automatically turn a car into homeowners-covered personal property. Homeowners policies generally exclude vehicles that are designed for road use or registration, even if an older vehicle is currently unregistered. If you keep an old vehicle in the garage, ask your agent whether it should remain on an auto policy and what coverage is appropriate.
Could two claims mean two deductibles?
When the home and vehicle are damaged in the same fire, there may be a homeowners claim and a separate comprehensive auto claim. Some insurance companies offer a multi-policy benefit that applies only the higher deductible when both policies are with that company and one event causes both covered losses. Other companies may apply each policy’s deductible separately.
This benefit is not universal, but it can save hundreds of dollars at claim time. It is one reason to compare policy features and claim benefits—not price alone.
A simple coverage check
- Does each vehicle have comprehensive coverage?
- What is the comprehensive deductible?
- If one loss affects both the home and auto, does the carrier offer a single-deductible benefit?
- Is an unregistered or collectible vehicle still properly insured?
- Would the coverage still make sense based on the vehicle’s current value?
- Is any vehicle stored seasonally or used differently than when the policy was written?
These are much easier questions to answer before a fire or other loss occurs.
Watch the video
We are here to help
Insurance claims often involve more than one policy, and small coverage details can make a big difference. VanScoter Insurance Agency can help you understand how your homeowners and auto policies work together and identify possible gaps.
Call us at (585) 663-2004 to schedule a coverage review.
Coverage varies by policy, carrier, and the facts of a loss. This article provides general information and does not alter or guarantee coverage. Please review your policy and speak with a licensed insurance professional.
